Content from MERGE Madrid 26

The institutional conference on crypto and Web3 connecting Europe and Latin America.

5.000+ Attendees
250+ Speakers
2x per year

MiCA vs GENIUS: Reserves, Yield and Stablecoin Supervision

The EBA, Banco de Portugal, Asensi Abogados and MK Fintech Partners compare at MERGE Madrid 2026 the European and US regulation of stablecoins: reserves, remuneration, significant issuers, risks for banks and mutual recognition

Date: 29/10/2026
10:00h. - 10:40h.
Place: MERGE Stage

40min · Full recording from 29/10/2026 at MERGE Stage. Also available on YouTube.

Overview

How do the European and US rules for stablecoins differ? In this MERGE Madrid 2026 panel, moderated by MiCA Crypto Alliance, Desislava Petrova, Senior Supervision Officer for MiCA at the European Banking Authority (EBA), Carlos António, Regulatory Policy Expert at Banco de Portugal, Carmen Arjona García, Corporate & Digital Assets Lawyer at the Spanish law firm Asensi Abogados, and Justine Scerri Herrera, Founder & Partner at MK Fintech Partners, compare MiCA with the US GENIUS Act. The debate comes two years after MiCA began to apply to stablecoins and one year after GENIUS was passed. The panel reviews reserves, remuneration, the supervision of significant issuers, the risks for banks and the path towards a less fragmented market.
Below the session summary, this page also explains what MiCA and the GENIUS Act are, compares them point by point (issuer eligibility, reserves, supervision and the yield ban), looks at what changes for stablecoins once GENIUS takes effect and lists where the two regimes agree.

What you'll learn

  • Two approaches: MiCA regulates the whole crypto-asset market and GENIUS only payment stablecoins
  • Reserves: minimum bank deposits in Europe versus liquidity management in the United States
  • Remuneration: what issuers and platforms can offer under each regime
  • Significant issuers: how the EBA assesses them and what changes in supervision
  • Risks for banks: liquidity, disintermediation and the Basel standards
  • Fragmentation: mutual recognition, multi-issuance and cooperation between supervisors

Session summary

The EBA's role as a direct supervisor

The EBA explains that, for the first time in its history, it is becoming a direct supervisor. It has classified USDC, issued by Circle, as the Union's first significant e-money token, effective from 12 November 2026. MiCA sets seven criteria and meeting three is enough. The assessment combines quantitative data, supplied by the issuers themselves, with qualitative criteria detailed in a delegated regulation, and it is repeated every year.

Two regulatory techniques

Asensi Abogados points out that MiCA regulates the crypto-asset market as a whole, so stablecoins are just one chapter, whereas GENIUS focuses on payment stablecoins. MiCA classifies by the reference asset and GENIUS by function. Reserves differ too: GENIUS starts from a closed list of assets and MiCA requires bank deposits alongside other instruments. In addition, the US law provides for recognising issuers from countries with a comparable regime, something the European Union does not offer for third-country stablecoins.

Remuneration and reserves

MK Fintech Partners recalls that MiCA prevents both issuers and service providers from offering interest, while in the United States platforms can offer rewards, which in its view leaves Europe at a disadvantage. On reserves, it criticises the 30% minimum in bank deposits, rising to 60% for significant tokens, because it concentrates risk in banks, and prefers the US emphasis on liquidity management and diversification. It sees the MiCA review as an opportunity to bring the two regimes closer.

Lessons from two years of MiCA

The EBA highlights three. The first is definitions: for e-money tokens the scheme is simple, but it is not always easy to draw the line between an asset-referenced token and a financial instrument, which is why it issues classification opinions at the request of national authorities. The second is financial resilience: the liquidity and reserve rules work well, although the mandatory percentages in deposits create a link with banks that needs watching, and the authority has asked for those thresholds to be reconsidered in the consultation on the MiCA review. The third is cooperation between supervisors, including those outside the Union, which now starts from day one. The moderator notes that there are dozens of e-money tokens and no asset-referenced token above the exemption threshold.

What concerns the banking supervisor

For Banco de Portugal, what matters most is how reserves are managed and that redemption is prompt and at par, whether the issuer is a bank or an e-money institution. It identifies three risks to financial stability: liquidity mismatch, bank disintermediation if funds move into stablecoins, with an effect on banks' funding and its cost, and runs. In its view, MiCA includes more safeguards and the European legislator has been more prudent than the US one.

Basel and capital requirements

Banco de Portugal recalls that MiCA and GENIUS regulate issuance and the offer to the public, whereas the Basel standard on crypto-asset exposures sets how much capital banks must allocate. It distinguishes a lower-risk group, with tokenized traditional assets and stablecoins, and a higher-risk group, with unbacked crypto assets and exposure limits. Europe has partly incorporated it into its capital requirements rules, with a transitional period.

Where regulation is heading

Asensi Abogados argues for a global market and for revisiting European rules in order to be competitive. MK Fintech Partners asks for burdens to be eased, such as the double licence for those who hold and transfer e-money tokens, and for progress on multi-issuance and mutual recognition. The EBA explains that its priority is shifting from authorisation to supervision and that information should flow between supervisors as easily as a stablecoin moves from one wallet to another. Banco de Portugal sees regulation as an enabler that adapts and expects the capital rules to reflect the final Basel standard.

What is MiCA? The EU's framework for stablecoin regulation

MiCA is the European Union's comprehensive rulebook for crypto-assets. It entered into force in 2023 and rolled out in phases: EMT and ART rules have applied since 30 June 2024; the wider framework, including most rules for crypto-asset service providers, has applied since 30 December 2024. Unlike the US approach, MiCA regulates the entire crypto-asset market, so stablecoins are one chapter within a much larger text.
Crucially, MiCA does not have a category called "stablecoin." Instead, every stablecoin falls into one of two regulated buckets: e-money tokens and asset-referenced tokens. The distinction drives everything else, from who can issue to how reserves must be structured. For a fuller walkthrough of the licensing regime, see our guide to the MiCA license.

E-money tokens (EMTs) under MiCA

An e-money token references a single official currency, so a euro-pegged or dollar-pegged stablecoin is an EMT. The issuer pool is deliberately narrow: a single-currency stablecoin (EMT) can only be issued by an authorized credit institution or electronic money institution. Issuers must publish a white paper, maintain fully segregated reserves, and honour redemption at par. MiCA also layers EMT-specific obligations on top of the existing Electronic Money Directive framework, so issuers carry both regimes at once.

Asset-referenced tokens (ARTs)

An asset-referenced token references anything other than a single currency: a basket of currencies, commodities, or other crypto-assets. A basket or asset-referenced stablecoin (ART) requires the issuer to be specifically authorized under MiCA Title III or be a credit institution. In practice, the market has overwhelmingly chosen EMTs, and ART issuance remains rare. When an ART or EMT grows large enough, the European Banking Authority steps in as a direct supervisor, a mechanism covered in the comparison below.

The stablecoin remuneration ban in Europe

One of MiCA's most consequential design choices is its treatment of yield. For both EMTs and ARTs, interest to holders is prohibited. The rationale is financial stability: regulators do not want stablecoins competing directly with insured bank deposits or draining funding from the banking system. The ban reaches not only issuers but also the service providers distributing these tokens, which closes the door on the "earn" products common elsewhere. This is where the EU and US frameworks part company most visibly.

What is the GENIUS Act? The US approach to payment stablecoins

The GENIUS Act, formally the Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for US Stablecoins Act, is the first federal law governing payment stablecoins. Where MiCA regulates the whole market, GENIUS focuses narrowly on payment instruments: a payment stablecoin is a digital asset an issuer must redeem at a fixed value, used for payment or settlement.
On timing, the law is in force but phasing in. The law becomes effective the earlier of 18 months after its date of enactment or 120 days after federal agencies issue final regulations implementing the Act, with the licensing requirement landing on 18 January 2027.

Who can issue stablecoins under the GENIUS Act?

The Act creates three domestic routes. Three classes of entity can issue a payment stablecoin under the GENIUS Act: a subsidiary of an insured depository institution, a federally qualified nonbank issuer supervised by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), or a state-qualified issuer. The state route carries a hard ceiling: payment stablecoin issuers with not more than $10 billion in total outstanding issued payment stablecoins may opt for regulation under a state-level regulatory regime as long as that regime is "substantially similar" to the federal regulatory framework. Cross that line and state-qualified issuers that exceed $10 billion in consolidated outstanding stablecoin issuance must transition to federal (OCC) oversight within 360 days or obtain a waiver.
Foreign issuers get a separate lane. For the exception to apply, foreign issuers must be subject to regulation and supervision by a foreign country that is comparable to the requirements under this act, as determined by Treasury. The foreign issuer must also be registered with the OCC and hold sufficient reserves in a US financial institution.

Reserve requirements under the GENIUS Act

The reserve mandate is the core of the law. Issuers are required to hold at least one dollar of permitted reserves for every one dollar of stablecoins issued. Permitted reserves center on cash and short-term US government paper, and the law deliberately steers issuers away from bank-deposit concentration: the GENIUS Act steers issuers toward Treasury bills and away from bank-deposit concentration. Transparency is enforced through reporting: issuers must publish monthly reserve reports examined by a registered public accounting firm, with CEO and CFO certifications, and issuers above $50 billion outstanding must produce annual audited financials.

MiCA vs GENIUS Act: head-to-head comparison

Both frameworks share a goal, consumer protection and financial stability, but they get there through very different mechanics. MiCA classifies stablecoins by their reference asset and regulates the whole market around them; GENIUS classifies by function and regulates only payment stablecoins.

Reserve requirements compared

  • Backing ratio: MiCA (EMT/ART): 1:1 for EMTs; GENIUS Act: 1:1 for payment stablecoins
  • Eligible assets: MiCA (EMT/ART): Bank deposits plus low-risk liquid assets; GENIUS Act: US dollars, Treasury bills, central bank reserves
  • Deposit floor: MiCA (EMT/ART): 30% in bank deposits (60% for significant tokens); GENIUS Act: No mandated deposit floor; Treasury-weighted
  • Custody rules: MiCA (EMT/ART): Segregated, bankruptcy-remote; GENIUS Act: Segregated, redemption-protected
The sharpest contrast sits in the reserve mix. Under MiCA, reserves backing significant EMTs and ARTs must be held primarily in highly liquid financial instruments, with at least 30% of the reserve held as deposits at credit institutions for non-significant tokens and at least 60% for tokens classified as significant. MiCA also caps concentration: no more than 25% of the cash reserve may sit with a single credit institution for non-significant tokens, dropping to 10% for significant tokens. GENIUS takes the opposite posture, pushing issuers toward Treasury bills rather than bank deposits.

Issuer eligibility and licensing

MiCA restricts EMT issuance to credit institutions and e-money institutions established in the EU, with EU-wide passporting once authorised. GENIUS offers the bank subsidiary, OCC-supervised nonbank, and state-qualified pathways, with the $10 billion threshold functioning as an automatic escalation mechanism from state to federal oversight. There is no GENIUS equivalent to MiCA's single-passport mechanism yet; the state regimes operate nationally only once certified as substantially similar.

EBA significant issuer supervision vs federal oversight

MiCA's most novel feature is the escalation to the European Banking Authority. Under Article 43 of Regulation (EU) 2023/1114, the EBA designates a token significant only when it meets at least three of seven criteria: more than 10 million holders; issued value, market capitalisation or reserve size above EUR 5 billion; more than 2.5 million transactions per day and more than EUR 500 million in daily transaction value, alongside further qualitative tests. This is no longer theoretical. On October 14, 2026, the European Banking Authority classified USDC as the EU's first significant e-money token, and from 12 November 2026 the token comes under the dual supervision that MiCA reserves for significant e-money tokens. The EBA reviews the classification every year, and a significant issuer follows stricter reserve, custody, liquidity and own-funds rules, with an independent reserve audit every six months. In the US, primary oversight sits with the OCC for federal nonbanks or the state regulator below the threshold, with no single pan-national supervisor playing the EBA's role.

Stablecoin remuneration: Europe's full ban vs the US issuer ban

This is the divergence with the biggest competitive stakes, and it is widely misunderstood. GENIUS is not silent on yield. The Act prohibits permitted payment stablecoin issuers and foreign payment stablecoin issuers from paying payment stablecoin holders any form of interest or yield, whether in cash, tokens or other consideration, solely in connection with the holding, use, or retention of such payment stablecoin. The practical gap is elsewhere: the US issuer ban does not clearly reach third-party exchanges and platforms offering rewards on stablecoin balances, a so-called third-party yield loophole. MiCA closes that door by extending its prohibition to service providers, not just issuers. So the real comparison is not "ban vs no ban" but "ban on issuers and distributors" (MiCA) versus "ban on issuers, with a platform-level gap" (GENIUS).

What happens to stablecoins after the GENIUS Act takes effect?

With a federal rulebook in place, the expectation is that regulated issuers move off the sidelines. For anyone who holds, builds with, or routes stablecoins, it converts a patchwork of state money-transmitter rules into one federal standard, which lowers the compliance uncertainty that kept some banks and fintechs cautious.
The two largest dollar stablecoins face different paths. Circle has pursued compliance proactively on both sides of the Atlantic, with USDC and EURC authorized since Circle obtained a French e-money institution license on 1 July 2024, which made it one of the first large dollar stablecoin issuers authorised in the EEA. Tether sits in the foreign-issuer lane, where its US treatment hinges on a Treasury comparability determination for its home regime. There is also a cross-border tension to watch: because platform-level rewards remain possible in the US while MiCA bans them outright, a yield-oriented US product could attract EU-domiciled capital and keep pressure on Europe's remuneration rules.

Points of convergence: where MiCA and the GENIUS Act agree

For all their differences, the two regimes share foundations:
  • Full backing, no algorithmic designs. Both demand 1:1 reserves, effectively ruling out uncollateralised algorithmic stablecoins.
  • Redemption at par. Holders can redeem at face value under both frameworks.
  • AML obligations. Permitted payment stablecoin issuers are considered "financial institutions" for purposes of the Bank Secrecy Act, mirroring MiCA's anti-money-laundering expectations.
  • Not securities. The GENIUS Act excludes payment stablecoins issued by permitted issuers from the definition of a security under federal securities laws, and payment stablecoins are also excluded from the definition of a commodity under federal commodities law. MiCA similarly carves EMTs and ARTs out of MiFID instrument treatment.
These shared pillars are what make future equivalence or mutual-recognition discussions plausible, even if they remain years away.

Global industry implications of two stablecoin regimes

Divergence between MiCA and GENIUS creates real compliance complexity for any issuer serving both markets: a stablecoin can be fully MiCA-compliant and still need a different reserve mix, issuer structure, and distribution model to meet US rules. That dual-compliance challenge is exactly the kind of question institutional actors are now working through in person.
Other jurisdictions, from the UK to Singapore and the UAE, are watching the EU-US dynamic closely as they finalise their own stablecoin rules. The practical takeaway for issuers is unchanged: build for both regimes now, because harmonisation, while desirable, is not imminent.

Conclusion: two roads to stablecoin legitimacy

MiCA and the GENIUS Act are converging on the same destination, trustworthy, fully reserved stablecoins, by different roads. MiCA is live, prescriptive, and already producing a named significant issuer under direct EBA supervision. GENIUS is enacted but mid-implementation, more permissive on reserve composition and with a platform-level yield gap that Europe has deliberately closed. The two most consequential divergences, the reach of the remuneration ban and the EBA's significant-issuer escalation, are precisely the areas issuers should model first.
The practical advice is unchanged: assess which markets you serve, and build compliance frameworks for both regimes now rather than betting on near-term harmonisation. Staying close to primary sources, the EU Official Journal, ESMA, the EBA, Treasury and the OCC, remains the only reliable way to track where both frameworks head next.

Key takeaways on MiCA and the GENIUS Act

  • MiCA is live and prescriptive; GENIUS is law but still phasing in. MiCA's stablecoin rules have applied since 30 June 2024, while GENIUS issuers need a licence from 18 January 2027.
  • Both demand 1:1 reserves, but MiCA mandates a bank-deposit floor (30%, rising to 60% for significant tokens) while GENIUS steers reserves toward Treasury bills.
  • The remuneration gap is the key divergence. Both ban issuers from paying yield, but MiCA also bans service providers, closing the platform-level loophole the US leaves open.
  • Europe has a direct supervisor. The EBA classified USDC as the EU's first significant e-money token on October 14, 2026, triggering dual supervision.
  • Plan for dual compliance. Global issuers must map which markets they serve and build to the stricter of the two regimes.

Watch the full talk

Watch the full recording of the panel in the video on this page, with the EBA, Banco de Portugal, Asensi Abogados and MK Fintech Partners on MiCA, GENIUS and the future of stablecoin regulation.

FAQs

What is the main difference between MiCA and GENIUS?

According to Asensi Abogados, MiCA regulates the whole crypto-asset market and classifies by the reference asset, while GENIUS regulates only payment stablecoins and looks at their function.

What does it mean for a stablecoin to be significant in the European Union?

According to the EBA, that it meets at least three of MiCA's seven criteria and that the European authority takes on part of its direct supervision. The assessment is repeated every year.

Can stablecoins offer interest?

According to MK Fintech Partners, MiCA prevents issuers and service providers from doing so, while in the United States platforms can offer rewards.

What risks do stablecoins pose for banks?

According to Banco de Portugal, liquidity mismatch, the loss of deposits and higher funding costs, and runs.

What happens to stablecoins after the GENIUS Act?

GENIUS is already law. The GENIUS Act was signed into law on July 18, 2025, and issuers need a licence from 18 January 2027. The expected effect is clearer federal rules bringing regulated bank and fintech issuers into the market, while large foreign issuers like Tether navigate the comparability-determination pathway.

What is MiCA crypto regulation?

MiCA is the EU's comprehensive crypto-asset framework. EMT and ART rules have applied since 30 June 2024; the wider framework, including most rules for crypto-asset service providers, has applied since 30 December 2024. It regulates stablecoins as either e-money tokens or asset-referenced tokens, each with strict reserve, redemption, and issuer rules.

Who can issue stablecoins under the GENIUS Act?

Three classes of entity can issue a payment stablecoin: a subsidiary of an insured depository institution, a federally qualified nonbank issuer supervised by the OCC, or a state-qualified issuer. State regulation is limited to issuers with a stablecoin issuance of $10 billion or less, above which an issuer must transition to federal oversight.

Is XRP considered a stablecoin?

No. XRP is a native crypto-asset with a floating market price, not a token redeemable at a fixed value, so it fails the GENIUS definition of a payment stablecoin. Under MiCA it falls outside the EMT and ART categories and is treated as another crypto-asset. For the difference between pegged and floating tokens, see our explainers on what a stablecoin is and fiat vs stablecoins.

Does the GENIUS Act allow interest-bearing stablecoins?

Not from issuers. The Act prohibits permitted and foreign payment stablecoin issuers from paying holders any form of interest or yield solely in connection with holding the stablecoin. The difference from MiCA is that the US ban centers on issuers, leaving a gap for third-party platform rewards, whereas MiCA extends the prohibition to service providers as well.
This page is a recap of a conference session plus general background on the topic. It is for information only and is not investment, legal or tax advice. Crypto-assets are volatile and you can lose money. Read the risk notice.

Moderator
This is MERGE

Where banks, regulators and the crypto ecosystem sit at the same table.

MERGE returns to Buenos Aires with 4,000+ attendees and 250+ speakers. A private Institutional Summit, two days at the Palacio Libertad, and the networking that moves the industry in Latin America.

Next edition → BUENOS AIRES
March 8–10, 2027 Institutional summit · Main conference · Palacio Libertad
MERGE Buenos Aires 2027
MERGE Buenos Aires 2027
MERGE Buenos Aires 2027
MERGE Buenos Aires 2027
Web3 | Metaverse | NFTs | Crypto | Digital Assets | Blockchain | Extended Reality